Methodology

Record coverage.
Reviewer experience.

PI Data Hub separates the completeness of a research record from the experiences described in published reviews.

Record coverage grades

A record coverage grade describes PI Data Hub’s record of a firm: how complete it is and how well each value is sourced. It is not a rating of the firm. A lower grade means we hold less, older or less well sourced information about the firm. It says nothing about the firm itself.

Eleven fields earn up to 100 points. Each field earns its points from the source rows on file for it. A value read from the firm’s own website, from a bar or regulator record, or confirmed by a person earns full credit. A Google Places listing earns 60 percent. A directory listing earns 50 percent. A derived value, such as a city-centroid coordinate, earns 30 percent and is labelled inferred. Two sources of different kinds that agree raise a field to full credit. Two directories agreeing do not, because directories carry the same feed. A field whose sources disagree earns nothing and costs a quarter of its points until the conflict is resolved.

Credit decays with the age of the observation. A value read a year ago earns half the credit of one read today, with a floor of 30 percent for any dated read. A value with no recorded observation date earns 20 percent. Three bonuses add up to 20 points on top, and the score is capped at 100: a dated research brief, a verified appearance in a published conference program, and a record a person confirmed against the firm’s own site. The dated bonuses decay on the same curve. A fully sourced, recently read record holds the highest grade with no bonus at all.

Bands are AAA+: 95 to 100; AAA: 90 to below 95; AA: 80 to below 90; A: 70 to below 80; B: 55 to below 70; C: 40 to below 55; D: below 40. A profile without a recorded score is unscored. One documented attorney or office earns the same credit as a hundred, so a small firm can hold the highest grade. The grade counts where and when each value was read, not whether the firm is good.

Record grade 2.0 field weights (100 points) and bonuses (up to 20 points, capped at 100)
FieldPoints
Firm name12
City8
State5
Website15
Phone10
Street address12
Practice areas15
Attorney count8
Office count5
Google rating5
Office geocode5
Dated research brief8
Verified conference appearance6
Record confirmed by a person6

Website technology and the chat, Spanish-language and consultation detections are shown where recorded but no longer earn grade points, because they come from one undated crawl. Bar association pages show record coverage as the number of documented fields out of eight.

Review verification and publication

The submission workflow requires email confirmation for each review and moderator approval before publication. Attorney reviewers supply a bar state and number; publication requires a moderator’s recorded bar-verification confirmation. Other professional reviewers use a work email domain. Reviews from staff of the reviewed firm are not accepted.

Email confirmation establishes control of an email address. Published reviews describe the reviewer’s experience and opinions; they are not independent findings about a case or a lawyer’s performance.

Editorial and moderation policy

PI Data Hub reserves editorial and moderation discretion, subject to applicable law, to decline, withhold or remove submissions. Submission does not guarantee publication. We may reject content that is irrelevant, unverifiable, misleading, duplicative, promotional, abusive, conflicted, or that contains confidential, privileged or identifying case information. These standards apply to favorable and unfavorable reviews. A reviewer or firm may request review of a publication decision; PI Data Hub makes the editorial decision.

Reviews must concern first-hand experience and must not be submitted in exchange for compensation or incentives. Firm responses are subject to moderation, with one published response per review. Published ratings summarize approved reviews, not all submissions or all clients’ experiences.

Review policies are applied subject to the FTC Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule and other applicable law.

Review information

A published review can include its written text, relationship to the firm, reviewer role, attorney bar state, case year, ratings, publication date and a moderated firm response. Name and email fields collected for verification are excluded from the public review response.

Structured matter answers, including recovery bands, are currently collected for internal research and moderation and are not released as matter-level answers or aggregates. Do not include client names, identifying case details, confidential information or privileged communications in review text.

Review averages and rankings

An overall review score averages four ratings: communication, transparency, outcome satisfaction and willingness to refer. Referral-fee and respect ratings are separate measures. A firm average is displayed when published reviews are available; ranking eligibility requires at least five published reviews.

For eligible review rankings, the 1–5 average is converted to a 0–100 display score using (average − 1) × 25, then mapped to the A/B/C/D/F bands. This review grade is separate from record coverage. Rankings use the selected geographic cohort before a name search; equal scores share a rank. Imported Google ratings are attributed separately and are excluded from the first-party review average.

Sources, dates and corrections

Research records draw on directory imports, firm websites, enrichment observations and submitted corrections. Observation dates refer to the recorded source check; processing dates refer to data processing. Corrections apply to the fields reviewed.

Use a profile’s correction link or contact PI Data Hub with the affected record, proposed correction and supporting source.

Research tools

Firm profiles, source-linked research drafts and research prompts support market research. Record coverage, historical business signals and reviewer experience are distinct measures and retain their respective labels. Workspace access is provisioned separately from a correction, review submission or request to claim a page.